top of page
Day-4

utopia

A song of Renaissance.

Thomas More's Utopia

Thomas More's Utopia illustrates his ideal society, where civillians follows certain guidelines throughout their life. By doing in this way Thomas More beleives that the society would be better than the society in reality.

Society Versus Individual

Thomas More's Utopia casts out a conflict between society and individual because sometimes what we think the best for the whole society may not benifit for individuals. In Thomas More's Utopia, More mentions that his utopians would only have a sole persue â€“ agriculture. On the surface it may seems as a compassionate idea that the whole population is working towards a same goal without a dissent. However, what if someone wants to be a writer or a doctor? Noticing that humans are not robots, utopians are therefore by no means to have sole perspective. If so, then there is no point for the elders to hold annual discussions since the society will continue in this fashion forever without an opposition.

 

On the other way around, to fulfill the needs of an individual may also harm the society. We have been learning Inter-war Years in humannities throughout this semester. In USSR, the ideology of communism is that the while property is own by the society and everyone receives a fixed amount. What this implies is that everyone gets the same results however hard they work. In a short term it may sound tempting and entincing for individuals, but in a long term this is undermining the society, thus causing those "extreme joyful" civilians starving to death.

The Search for the Perfect World

The aim fo Thomas More's Utopia is to search for a better world. More suggests that society would be better if only we could get rid of the disgraces in humans such as laziness, greed, or poverty.

Discussion: Will utopia ever be an better society for humans?

After reading Thomas More's Utopia, I have written down my ideal society. These are the rules for my utopia:

 

  • I would like to set my utopia in a tropical island with sea surrounded.

  • I would like to set a democratic form of government, which elections would be held every three years among utopians.

  • I would like to have utopians to speak identical language.

  • I would like to set strict laws for utopians.

  • I would like to have utopians to born with different advantages and disadvantages.

 

As the terms show above, I tried to find the balance  point between individuals and society in order to contruct a better society. However, when I finally reach my "perfect" balance point, I recognized that my utopia is drifting towards to the real world, which technically makes no difference. The last term  "I would like to have utopians to born with different advantages and disadvantages." at some point goes against the idea of a typical utopia, where everyone has to be the same. Will utopia ever be a better society for humans? The answer for me is tentative, but it must either cater the rights of individuals or the whole society, not even mentioning one's utopia may be other's dystopia.

 

bottom of page